Legendary singer Cher appeared on Watch What Happens: Live Thursday evening, making host Andy Cohen’s dream come true as he introduced what he called “Cher-mageddon” to the set. The multi-award winning icon dished on everything from stealing a horse as a teen to her favorite lover.

During Cher’s visit to Watch What Happens Live, nothing was off limits for “Believe in Life after Love” singer Entertainment Weekly reports. Cohen asked Cher during a game of “Truth or Cher” who she would say was her “favorite lover.”

According to People , Cher replied, “Well, a lot of them kind of came in first…I had just the greatest lovers ever.” When pressed for an answer she responded that actor Tom Cruise, whom she dated in the 1980’s, easily made the top 5.

Unfortunately for viewers, Cher would divulge who the other four lovers who made the top five are.

Among the other notable highlights, Cher admitted to stealing a horse when she was 13, loving the 80s because she could “swim naked” and when asked if she has ever had a lesbian lover she coyly responded, “Who hasn’t?”

Check out some clips from her time with Cohen in the video below:

Image: NBC/Bravo