For breakfast Giles has served everyone steak and eggs, but Don and Dana’s steaks are bloody and Giles says that if anyone wants to cook their food they can go into the kitchen. Don goes in there to cook his raw steak and a mountain lion attacks and kills him. Everyone hears the noise in the kitchen and takes off running. Giles tell them to be careful and not go in there and to wait. He then goes and gets a tranquilizer gun and goes in and shuts the door and shoots the lion.
Later Giles comes into the living room and states that the mountain lion was not harmed, just tranquilized and then tells everyone that they can investigate either the Crime Scene which is the kitchen, the Morgue, or a new location which is the mountain lion itself. Geno and Ronny decide that they want their group to split up so that they can watch the other group.
Kam pulls his team to the side and Melina says that it is now 5 against 4. Kam says he doesn’t trust Lindsey, and tells her that she is playing both sides. Lindsey tells him that she is not and that she needs to stay in his group.
When they break up into teams to do investigations Ronny, Dana, Kam and Lindsey go to the kitchen and while there Kam says that Lindsay needs to be chaperoned wherever she goes because she can’t be trusted. They all notice that there is not a lot of blood in kitchen and that there are two paw prints on the stove. At this point Lindsey wonders where the mountain lion could have come from, and then all of a sudden the dumbwaiter opens and they see an open cage inside of it. They all then wonder how it opens and Ronny sees that there is a pressure pad mat that opens up the dumbwaiter when you step on it because it is rigged from underneath to do so.
Dana says that with her nursing experience she notices that there is not enough blood around, so the lion couldn’t have been what killed Don. Ronny tries to retrace Don’s steps, and in doing so he notices the heater coil on the stove might have been what killed Don. He doesn’t want Lindsey and Kam to know what he discovered so he distracts them so that they won’t figure out what he is doing.
Geno and Cris go and examine the mountain lion and notice that it has blood on its paws and mouth, and part of a raw steak inside of it. Around its neck there are tags that say "special delivery, no quick or sudden movements and keep small kids away". They realize that the lion was actually delivered to Rue Manor.
At the morgue, Melina, Sasha & Ulysses realize that Don has reddish pink blood on his hands and face, a bad scratch on his right leg, claw marks, and a bite on his neck near his main artery, and also white powder on the front of his shirt.
When everyone meets up again to discuss what has happened they break up into their personal groups. Sasha says that she noticed red/pink coloring on Don’s body and Dana says it could have been an allergic reaction. While Ronny’s group is talking Cris and Lindsey spy on them and realize that no one trusts Lindsey. When Ronny realizes how much everyone in the house can’t stand or trust Lindsey, he comes up with a plan to have her eliminated, and sends Sasha and Melina to talk to Cris and Ulysses about getting rid of her.
Giles shows up with a clue that says “Today will take you out of your element. To find a clue that is most relevant, run to the place where the cool are laid back. Go ‘C’ ‘N’ to stay on the right track". They all run off with magnifying glasses and decide that they will not help Lindsey with the clue. Cris decides to go back to the morgue and she sees a table of elements on the wall and the clue is on there. The clue leads them upstairs to a closet. Lindsey opens the closet door and sees dinner napkins, but doesn’t really look at them, Geno however does and it gives him a code for a safe. When he finds the safe he sees a schematic plan inside that says that Don was gassed.
After everyone has done the State your Case, Geno tells them about the safe and the schematic plan and how Don was gassed by the cyanide when he turned on the stove. At this point everyone on Kam’s team is shocked because they didn’t have this information and they are afraid that one of them will die.
Giles appears at dinner and gives out the cards. He announces that the killer has Spared Dana and then explains how Don died.
He states that the killer said that Don was easy prey, and how Don hoped to cook his breakfast, but when he turned on the stove cyanide spit out and poisoned him. And when Don stepped on the mat the mountain lion emerged. It was hungry and bit Don, but ended up eating his steak instead and that the cyanide was the true cause of death.
Receiving Spared cards were Geno, Ronny, Melina, Sasha, Cris and Lindsey, while Kam and Ulysses receive Scared cards
At this point Giles receives a call from the killer, which actually ends up being a sliced version of the contestants saying that they are each the killer and to go to the horse stables for a ride.
In the morning everyone goes on a horseback ride with Giles and a bunch of birds fly out of the trees and frighten the horses. Giles tells everyone to stay calm; at this point Ulysses is thrown from his horse and killed.