It’s morning at the mansion and there is weird music playing and Geno rushes downstairs to see that Sasha and Dana are lifeless at the piano. Everyone rushes downstairs and comments about how cold the room is. Giles comes in and dances with one of the maids and then tell the guests that they can examine the morgue, and Sasha and Dana’s bedrooms. Cris and Melina look at Dana’s room, Lindsey and Geno examine Sasha’s room and Kam and Ronnie investigate the morgue. In each of the bedrooms there are huge male footprints on the rugs in the hallway and smaller female footprints as well as wheel tracks and a white face cloth with lipstick on it. Everyone notices blood drops in the hallway that leads to an elevator. Melina and Cris use a metal device to open the door to Dana’s room which also has marks on the rug and blood spots leading to the elevator. The device allows them to open the locked door of her room from the inside while they are standing outside.
While Kam and Ronnie are at the morgue Kam comments about how happy he is that Sasha is gone, and he notices that Sasha has a deep knife wound on her left forearm and that Dana has one on her right. The guys notice that there are cloth-like fibers in both Dana and Sasha’s noses. Dana has blood on her pajamas, and slashes on her back, but Sasha’s doesn’t seem to have anything wrong with her. Kam comes up with a plan to get rid of Geno, and asks Ronnie to help him, Ronnie doesn’t want to completely shut out Geno, and so he lies to him instead. Geno sees Ronnie giving Melina eye contact and realizes that Ronnie is withholding information from him.
Giles appears and takes everyone to a theater inside the mansion and they see life size dummies of themselves. They watch a silent movie that gives them a riddle that involves the word key, and tells them to be on the lookout for double snowmen. Geno comes up with the idea that snowmen are in the shape of the number 8, and that two snowmen mean 88, and that the word key would refer to piano keys since pianos have 88 keys. When he gets to the piano where Sasha and Dana were found dead he finds a clue, a scalpel. He takes the scalpel back to his dummy and starts cutting it open. Everyone figures out the piano clue and then go to their dummies. Cris realizes that there’s another clue in the dummies back. She takes off with the clue and heads to the morgue and finds a hidden wall leading to a second morgue, which looks like a torture chamber. She finds blood around the sink and the dolly/cart that was used, and also some men’s size 13 shoes that are stuffed with paper.
After giving their accusations to the killer during the State your Case they go in for dinner and Giles appears. He says that Kam has been spared by the killer, and gives out Scared and Spared cards. Cris, Melina, and Lindsey all get Spared and Ronnie and Geno both get Scared cards. Giles explained how the killer committed the murders. The killer used a door-opening gizmo to sneak into the victims' rooms. Wearing the size 13 shoes that are stuffed with paper, the killer chloroformed Sasha, put her in the dolly cart, went into Dana’s room and at knife point made her push the dolly cart with Sasha in it onto the elevator. When in the second morgue he chloroforms Dana then drains their blood and then redresses both of them in dinner party attire and puts them by the piano.
After dinner the guests go to a luau, and do the limbo, and then the lights go out, someone flashes a light and everyone sees that a chandelier has fallen on Geno and killed him.