We open on the gang still going through the jungle. David thinks Mary-Margaret needs a rest but she thinks he does. Emma then says they're near Pan's camp but then the map changes. Regina thinks Emma got them lost but Hook says that Pan moved the camp as a game.
Pan wakes up a sleeping Henry and throws him an Apple. Henry declines saying, "I don't like apples. It's a family thing." Pan then tells Henry that it isn't to eat. He wants him to use it for “target practice.”
Back in the Fairy Tale land, Neal tells Mulan and Robin Hood that he needs to find a portal to get to Neverland and Emma and Henry. Neal knows that Henry is in danger from Pan because that's the only reason Emma would be in Neverland. Then, Little John and Robin's young son, Roland, enter Rumplestiltskin' s castle. Neal then says that he knows how to get to Neverland.
Regina again says that they should use magic to find Pan's camp. Hook says that Pan's camp is shielded from magic which is why they're walking there. Hook then suggests using someone Pan trusts to find his camp, a fairy who has pixie dust which would enable them to fly into Pan's camp and grab Henry. Emma correctly assumes that Hook is talking about Tinkerbell. Regina thinks it's a bad idea.
Flashback to the past, Rumplestiltskin goes to see Regina, who is all alone in the castle. She tells him to go away. Regina tells Rumplestiltskin that she isn't sure she wants to continue her lessons with him. Regina then tells Rumplestiltskin that she "wants freedom. I need options." But, Rumplestiltskin replies that the darkness will inevitably feast upon her and she can't stop it. He then disappears. Regina goes to the balcony and bangs on the railing in frustration. It comes loose and she begins to fall but she's saved...by Tinkerbell. Regina tells Tinkerbell her problems (i.e. her hatred for Snow.) Tinkerbell says that Regina needs love and that she can use pixie dust to find Regina her soul mate.
Back to the present. Regina suggests to Emma that they combine their magic to find Pan's camp and Henry. Emma reminds Regina that using magic always comes with a price. Emma wants to see Hook' s plan to find Tinkerbell through. Regina then calls Hook Emma's "boyfriend." Mary-Margaret appears and reminds Regina that Emma just lost Neal. Regina apologizes.
In Pan's camp, Pan wants Henry to shoot an apple off a fellow Lost Boy's head with a Dreamshade-laced arrow. Henry doesn't want to but takes the bow, but instead of shooting the Lost Boy, he shoots the arrow at Pan, who stops it before it hits him and laughs. He then wants to show Henry something.
As they're continuing to walk, Hook tells David that he knows he was shot with a Dreamshade-laced arrow. He says he has mere days to live and urges him to tell Mary-Margaret but David refuses. David thinks the pixie dust could save him
Back in the past, Tinkerbell tells Regina that finding love will make her happy then tells her that she's late for an appointment but will be back. She then goes to meet another fairy she calls Blue. Blue tells Tinkerbell who Regina is and that she doesn't deserve Tinkerbell' s help but she disagrees. Blue then orders Tinkerbell to remain there so she can monitor her but as soon as Blue is out of sight, Tinkerbell leaves and goes back to Regina.
Neal asks Robin to have Roland summon The Shadow. He promises that it will take him to Neverland NOT Roland. Robin tells Neal that Roland is all he has since his wife died but reluctantly agrees because Rumplestiltskin saved Robin's wife long enough so she could have Roland. He then says that Roland just calls The Shadow once, no second chances. Neal agrees.
Emma assumes Regina did something to Tinkerbell because she's reluctant to find her. Regina tells Emma that they "have a complicated history." Regina says that if Tinkerbell sees her, she won't help them. Regina then tells Emma to get Henry, with or without Tinkerbell' s help. She has to stay out of sight.
Back to the past. Tinkerbell goes back to Regina with pixie dust, still eager to help her find happiness. She sprinkles her with it and they fly. As they're flying, Tinkerbell throws the pixie dust and tells Regina that it will show them her soul mate. They go into town and Tinkerbell points the man inside the tavern. who the pixie dust has made glow. He has a lion tattoo and will be the beginning of Regina' s happiness, Tinkerbell tells her. She then leaves Regina to go in the tavern and meet him but instead Regina runs away.
Back in the present. Tinkerbell finds Regina in the jungle and knocks her out with some sort of dust.
The gang finds Tinkerbell' s tree house but no pixie dust. They see Regina' s handkerchief and realize they're in the wrong place and that Tinkerbell has Regina.
Regina wakes up and Tinkerbell tells her that she knows that she's in Neverland to find Henry. Tinkerbell says that Regina ruined her life. Regina then says that Tinkerbell didn't knock her out with magic, which must mean she has none but Regina does and materializes a knife. Tinkerbell then proceeds to take out Regina’s heart and asks her if she knows what Dreamshade is. Regina says that she does. Tinkerbell replies, "Good." Regina then says, "How did you get like this?" Tinkerbell replies, "I met you."
Back in the past. Tinkerbell flies to see Regina to ask her how meeting her soulmate went. Regina lies and says the man the pixie dust made glow was horrible. Tinkerbell knows that she didn't go in and tells her it's okay to be scared. Regina replies that she's scared of nothing and says Tinkerbell is a "bad fairy." Regina then sends her away even though she tells her that she stole for her and now is in big trouble for nothing. Regina again rudely orders Tinkerbell to leave.
Back to the present. Regina dares Tinkerbell to crush her heart and kill her. It looks like Tinkerbell might and starts to crush Regina’s heart.
Back to the past. Tinkerbell flies away but Blue appears and tells her that she can't be forgiven for not listening to her about Regina. Tinkerbell begs for a second chance but Blue strips her of her wings.
Back to the present. Regina realizes she cost Tinkerbell her wings. Tinkerbell then asks Regina why she lied and didn't go in the tavern to meet her soul mate. "Was being happy such a terrible fate?" Tinkerbell asks Regina, who says, "Yes. You were right. I never went in. I was afraid. You said I could let go of the anger that was weighing me down and suddenly, I felt like without it I'd just float away. That anger was all I had. What would I be without it?" "Happy," Tinkerbell replies. "Weak," Regina says. Regina then tells Tinkerbell that she made the dark heart she's holding and its Tinkerbell' s future as well. Regina tells her that it's her choice, "Choose hope over anger and help me find my son." Tinkerbell then asks Regina if she loves Henry. She replies that she finally got something right with him. Tinkerbell still says that it's too late for her and adds that she won't kill Regina but won't help her either and that it’s probably too late anyway. Tinkerbell then gives Regina back her heart and walks away.
Pan tries to entice Henry to stay in Neverland because there he'll never be told, "No." Henry says that he doesn't belong there but Pan says they have been waiting for him since before he was even born. Henry doesn't believe him. Pan then tells Henry that he needs to save magic and he's the savior. He tells Pan that Emma is. Pan says that breaking the curse didn't make Emma the savior...having Henry did. Pan then gives Henry a scroll he says will prove he's the savior of magic. Henry throws the scroll on the ground and says he doesn't believe Pan. Pan then tells Henry that he reminds him if Neal and walks away.
Mulan gets everything ready for Roland to summon The Shadow. Neal thanks Robin, who tells him to thank him when his family is back together. Neal says he hopes he gets a second chance with Emma. Neal then tells Mulan that " when you love someone you say it. You don't keep it in." Robin then tells Roland not to be scared and he says the magic words, "I believe," but nothing happens. Neal begs Robin to let him say it again but Robin refuses. Suddenly, the window flies open and The Shadow flies in. It tries to take Roland but Mulan and Robin stop it. It retreats but not before Neal grabs it and they fly away together. Mulan asks Robin if Roland is okay. He says he's fine and thanks for her help saving him. He then asks her to join his Merry Men. She says she’s honored but declines because she has to "talk to someone before it's too late." "A loved one?" Robin asks. She replies, "We shall see."
Suddenly, Mulan is back with Aurora, who is overjoyed to see her. Mulan asks where Phillip is because she has news. Aurora then she has news too. She and Phillip are going to have a baby. Milan replies, "Excellent news" and they hug. Aurora then asks Milan about her news. She says she's joining Robin Hood’s Merry Men. Aurora says that she’s sad to see her leave. They hug and Mulan walks away crying and heartbroken.
The gang corners Tinkerbell and orders her to tell them where Regina is. Tinkerbell doesn't know who they are. Then, Regina appears and tells the gang that Tinkerbell won't hurt them. Hook asks if she's going to help them. Tinkerbell recognizes Hook. Regina says that she won't help but Hook begs her to mentioning their history. Then, Regina then tells them that Tinkerbell has no magic, pixie dust or wings. Tinkerbell doesn't say it's Regina’s fault and blames people for not believing in her anymore. She then says that even she had magic, etc. Pan is too powerful but knows where Pan's camp is. Emma begs Tinkerbell to get them inside. She wants to know why she should help them and what's in it for her. Mary-Margaret then says that she believes in her and adds that Tinkerbell can come home with them. Tinkerbell agrees and says Pan will let her in his camp her because he trusts her, but they’ll have only one shot to get Henry so they better have a good plan. Emma thanks Tinkerbell and they all start walking. David lingers behind and Mary-Margaret asks him if something is wrong. He says that he just wants to get Henry back and asks her how she knew saying she could come home with them would make her help them. She says when she was abandoned and living alone, all she wanted was a home but never found it until he came along. She asks him if he’s okay again. He says that he is and that he loves her. They kiss and follow after the others.
Henry picks up the scroll and unravels it. It’s a drawing of him.
The Shadow drops Neal in Neverland. The Lead Lost Boy appears and welcomes Neal/Baelfire back to Neverland and says that Pan will be happy to hear he’s returned.
The gang is camped out. Tinkerbell goes over to Regina and asks her if she ever went back to meet the man with the lion tattoo. Regina replies that she didn’t and Tinkerbell calls her selfish. Regina asks how her actions were selfish. “Because you didn’t just ruin your life. You ruined his,” Tinkerbell replies.
Mulan finds Robin and his Merry Men. He shakes her hand and welcomes her.