Elizabeth Olsen was put to task on Wednesday night’s Watch What Happens Live to pick which twin sister she likes the most, Mary-Kate or Ashley.
Surprisingly, Olsen did choose a sister: Ashley. The reason behind that is because Mary-Kate forgot her birthday this year.
When a caller asked her the difficult question, host Andy Cohen said, "Now this is a good question. There has to be one that is more in your favor today that you're more vibing on."
Us Weekly reports the In Secret star turned 25 on Feb. 16.
“Ashley remembered my birthday, but I don't hold grudges against Mary-Kate forgetting mine," she said, adding Mary-Kate is on vacation in Jamaica. "She was out of town! I should have just said my brother!"
Olsen said her sister is going to come home and “shoot me,” saying again she should’ve used their 29-year-old brother Trent as her “scapegoat” to that question.
Cohen stirred the pot, saying "I think, from the last time I was in Jamaica, text signals do work.”
The other guest on Watch What Happens Live Wednesday night was Jerry O’Connell.
image: NBC
