In the aftermath of the werewolf kidnapping, Josh finally woke up to Nora sitting on their bed. Even though she was there seeing he was alright, she wasn't sticking around. Josh began arguing that he really needed her, that she was the only thing human about him, when Sally started coming through their closet door.
At the end of last episode we thought Sally was sent back to the time of Lil Smokie. But with sledgehammer in hand, Aidan and Josh break through the closet wall to a room that was sealed up and preserved. It was the same room that Sally saw the little girl being killed in. There was a very old blood stain on the floor, but it had tally marks in it that looked fairly new.
As they were talking about it, the doorbell rang. Mr. Malik, Sally's dad came to the door. He told Josh and Aidan they had until the end of the week to move out. He had sold the house and needed to be done with it. They tried to beg him to at least give them some more time, but he refused.
All but Sally realized that this might be the end of their experiment and started to pack. Meanwhile, Ramona, the little girl who lived in the creepy sealed room, revealed herself. She told Sally she needed help talking to her sister.
Kenny called Aidan to come over to his office. As he walked in, Astrid and Kenny were arguing about something, but she quickly left. Kenny decided he and Astrid would run away together, but she was having reservations about leaving her pack. There has been a lot of tension between the vampires because some do not like the peace treaty Kenny has created with the werewolves.
Aidan said he would help Kenny fake his death by gathering all his subordinates and have them walk in on a fake pile of vampire ashes and a bloody stake in his hand. Kenny also asked if Josh and Nora would talk Astrid into leaving with him.
Back at home Josh was packing up his room when Aidan brought up the subject of Kenny and Astrid leaving together. Josh immediately refused to talk to her. He said even though he doesn't like Mark and the rest of the group, he understands why Astrid wants to stay with a group of her own rather than running away with a young vampire that could change his mind and kill her at any minute. Aidan was seriously offended, and started yelling at Josh. Sally came into the room to break it up, but then they all started yelling at each other. She eventually broke it up.
Having promised Ramona they would help her, Sally and Aidan went to the DMV to get her sister, who was now an old woman. While they were waiting they started talking about being together. Sally said didn't want to get hurt, and Aidan said he didn't want to totally destroy their relationship like always happens with him. They finally called his number so Aidan went up to Ramona's sister and tried to explain. She called security, and since everyone thought he was talking to himself since they couldn't see Sally, they escorted him out.
Meanwhile, Nora came over to the house to talk to Astrid, but Josh said he wouldn't be apart of it, so he went upstairs. The doorbell rang, so Nora let Astrid in. As soon as they got into the living room, Astrid pulled a gun and said she didn't want to, but they made her do it. Just then, Mark and the whole pack came in for Josh. Nora screamed for Josh, who ran for the door. Ramona appeared and shut the door. Josh began screaming at her to let him out. But she refused and said he can't fight them like this. Josh got angrier and angrier. The pack began to climb the stairs, saying they didn't want to hurt him and Nora is fine, they just wanted to show him the wolves that he created. They opened the door to find Josh in full wolf form.
Aidan and Sally returned from the DMV and found blood soaked walls and dead bodies scattered around the house. Josh killed them all to protect Nora, including Astrid who Nora tried to save but wasn't quick enough. Aidan said he would take care of it, and just to get out of there to change since it was a full moon.
Nora and Josh went out the RV when Sally showed up. She said she was going to possess Josh right as he was about to change to try and fix the spell she never got to finish. When she entered Josh she was sent to a snow covered forest where Josh was hiding. They saw Josh's wolf and began to run. Sally was trying to convince him to stop running and confront the wolf. He refused so she made him think of a safe place, which transported them to the house. As they were talking in the kitchen, the wolf walked in. Josh held out his hand to calm the wolf, which worked, and it calmly left the house. Josh woke up in the forest, and finally was back to normal.
Meanwhile, Kenny came over the house to clean up the werewolf bodies. Aidan told him that Astrid wasn't there, but that Mark killed her because she was going to leave with Kenny. He was so upset he was speechless. He returned to his office, and Sally, Josh, and Nora returned home to a clean house.
Back at his office, Kenny was sitting at his desk when Astrid came up to him crying. He tried to hug her, but his hand went right through her. She said that she didn't want to do it, but that Mark made her. Kenny didn't know what she was talking about. She then revealed that is was Josh who had killed her.
The episode ends with the empty creepy room Ramona lives in, and there were more tally marks in the blood stain.