A clip from a 2010 episode of Judge Judy is making its rounds on the internet five years later, which features a man incriminating himself in front of the tough TV judge.

When the plaintiff was reading off a list of items in the purse she accused two men of stealing, such as her wallet with $50 bill in it, gift cards and an earpiece, one of the co-defendants made it extremely easy for Judge Judy to come to a verdict.

“There was no earpiece in there,” he said and as soon he did, Judge Judy broke into a huge smile and squealed “I love it!” She then turned to the bailiff and pointed to the two defendants, calling them “dumb and dumber.”

Clearly, the only way he would know the contents of her purse is if he stole it and had it in his possession.

Judge Judge awarded the plaintiff $500 for her stolen property.

screenshot via YouTube video