Barbara is getting ready for her wedding to Jim. She walks down the isle and then her dream quickly becomes a nightmare as Penguin arrives and she quickly becomes upset. This will surely keep Barbara as unstable as always. She wakes up with a gift waiting for her.

Theo is up early in the morning and talks with Tabitha about how Jim is becoming a problem. They will need Barbara to distract him while he meets with Bruce to continue his plan to take control of Wayne Enterprises. He is going to give Bruce the one thing he wants. Theo promises Barbara today is the day she will kill Jim Gordon.

Jim is trying to convince Barnes that Theo is behind everything that has been happening. Barnes won’t condone an arrest without actual proof. In a shocking move, Barbara walks into GCPD and Jim takes her to an interrogation room. He tries to get her to talk, but she refuses and only plays mind games with him. He is skeptical to trust her but plays along to try and gain her trust. They know she is probably setting a trap but Jim wants to go along with it since she is their only link to Theo.

Bruce goes to Theo’s apartment and has a brief chat with Silver. He then talks with Theo and Theo asks him his dream. Bruce wants to find and kill the man who murdered his parents. Theo has plans for the city and hopes that they can help each other. Theo says he has been investigating Wayne Enterprises and has found plenty of corruption. Theo proposes that Bruce sell his company to him. Bruce is reluctant to sell but Theo has a hard pitch. Theo offers Bruce the identity of his parents killer if he sells him the company. Theo is giving him the day to think about it.  

Edward drives out into the forest to bury Ms. Kringle’s remains. He is giving his good-bye speech when a hunter stumbles across him. Edward knocks him out with a shovel and now must dispose of his body as well. Edward then sees a trail of blood leaving his picnic and is following to see where it leads to.

The GCPD strike force is getting ready to follow Barbra. Leslie is very against this idea. Jim and Bullock drive Barbra and follow her instructions. Jim tells her he knows this is all a trap. Barbra continues to try and manipulate Jim when out of nowhere a semi-truck crashes into their car and shootout breaks out between Theo’s men and GCPD. Jim/Bullock are banged up in the crash and Jim draws his gun on Barbara but Tabitha injects a needle into Jim’s neck.

Bruce is reading his father’s letter and asks Alfred for advice. He asks how long his training will take and tells Alfred about Theo’s offer. Alfred thinks she should refuse it and Bruce still seems torn. He wants to keep the company because it his parents’ legacy. Alfred tells Bruce that he is his parents legacy.

Barnes is setting up a perimeter to find Jim and tells Bullock to go home. Bullock goes to his desk and listens to the recording of the interrogation that took place earlier and hears Barbara mention a church. He tells Barnes that Barbara is holding them at Gotham Cathedral Church.

Jim is tied up into the church and Barbara wants another try at marrying Jim. She has kidnapped a priest, witnesses and even Leslie. She continues to torment both of them then threatens to kill Leslie. Jim finally is able to break free and draw a shotgun on Barbara. Tabitha and some of Theo’s men come in and shoot at them but GCPD arrives at the right time. Jim chases Barbara into the attic of the church. She tries to stab him but he dodges her and she breaks through the glass and Jim grabs her hand and she holds onto him. She tells Jim she loves him then lets go and falls.

Leslie tells Jim that Barbara is in critical condition and once this all calms down, they need to talk. GCPD raid the docks and find Mayor James still alive. Meanwhile, Bruce is moments away from signing his company over to Theo. Bruce decides at the last minute that he can’t do it. Jim and GCPD barge in and Jim punches Theo and tells him he is under arrest for kidnapping Mayor James. Bruce notices that Theo has thrown the documents containing his parents’ killer in the fire. Bruce is horrified.

Edward’s journey leads him to a trailer in the middle of the forest. He is trying to listen inside when the door swings open and knocks him down. Edward puts his glasses on and sees an injured Penguin come outside. “Help me!” Penguin pleads to a shocked Edward…