Lucius Fox emerges from inside the secret study at Wayne Manor to find no sign of Bruce or Alfred. An injured Alfred is continuing to evade Tabitha and is able to hide from her inside a box at the city dump moments before piles of trash are dumped on him.
Theo is holding Bruce prisoner and gives him a history refresher on their two families. He tells Bruce tonight he will be their final sacrifice and Father Creel promises that at midnight, the sins of the Wayne family will be washed away in Bruce’s blood.
Jim wakes up confused to see Penguin and Edward apparently friends and roommates. Penguin tells Jim they have a mutual interest…Theo Galavan. Penguin thinks they should work together.
Theo is disappointed when Tabitha returns without having found Alfred. They bicker for several moments before Silver tries to get out of attending the ceremony tonight. Theo tells Silver he is giving her one final test…make Bruce Wayne fall in love with her before he dies.
Barnes has put out an arrest warrant for Jim. Leslie is horrified and tries to reason with him, but Barnes wants to hear Jim’s innocence from his own mouth. Edward whispers an address and time for Leslie to find Jim. She arrives at that specific time and address to find Jim with Penguin, getting ready to attack Theo. He wants Leslie to leave town until this is over. She surprises him with the news that she is pregnant.
Silver visits Bruce in his cell and tries to apologize to him. She wants forgiveness from him but he wants nothing to do with it, or her. They make awkward small talk and Silver finally admits the truth and that she can’t watch him die. She persuades the guard for his gun and shoots him and they try to escape out the back but are cut off by Theo. They are quickly returned to the prison cell.
Alfred emerges from the trash and attempts to steal a car, but is apprehended by GCPD. We see Barnes, Fox, Alfred and Bullock talking about who has Bruce and where Jim is. Barnes says without hard evidence, they can’t go after Theo. Alfred knows Theo is having the ceremony and Edward gives them a riddle, revealing where Jim is.
Leslie and Jim are preparing to leave town when Alfred, Bullock and Fox arrive. Leslie immediately knows that Jim is going to stay. She tells him to call her when this is over. They are preparing to raid Theo’s ceremony but Penguin wants to kill Theo. Jim tells Penguin that he must be arrested so the people of Gotham know what kind of man he truly is. Selina appears and tells them she knows a way to get them in.
Silver confesses her love for Bruce. Bruce knows she is playing him. Theo arrives and tells Bruce it is time. Bruce first kisses Silver and tells her that he forgives her and loves her. Bruce is lead into the ceremonial room where Father Creel and everyone are waiting. They are chanting “death to the son of Gotham…”
Jim, Bullock, Alfred, Penguin and his men are marching towards the location while Selina takes out a guard and lets them in the back door. They are closing in on the ceremony.
Father Creel is moments away from stabbing Bruce when Silver stops him. This brief delay allows Jim and his group to arrive and confront them. The battle begins as they defeat the monks and Father Creel dives at Jim but is shot by a tardy Bullock. In the chaos, Theo escapes and is preparing to escape with Tabitha. He is moments away from killing Silver when Tabitha knocks him out and uses the parachutes for herself and Silver to escape the building.
Theo is hazy and is confronted by Jim. Jim seems conflicted whether to kill him or arrest him. Barnes arrives and tries to calm Jim down. Jim complies but Barnes is quickly knocked out by Penguin. He wants to kill Theo and tries to persuade Jim why they should do this.
We see Jim and Penguin take Theo out to the middle of nowhere where Penguin brutally beats him with a bat. Jim stops him, then shoots Theo in the chest…killing him. Jim walks away, seeming very conflicted over what he did.
Jim finds Leslie. He asks Leslie to marry him. She smiles at him. We see a GC Coroner truck arrive to Indian Hill research facility. We see them discover Theo’s body with Penguin’s umbrella in his mouth.
The final scene of the episode shows a man being chased by someone in a back alley. He is blocked in and we see a man approach him and shoot with what appears to be a freezing gun…