Gordon Ramsay is used to the high-pressure world of the culinary arts, but when he may have found his biggest challenge yet: Girl Scout Cookies.

Amazingly, Ramsay had never tried them before, so Jimmy Kimmel had the Hell’s Kitchen host try them since now is the time when we are all bombarded with scouts us to buy them.

First, Ramsay thought the Tagalongs, Thin Mints and Samoas were dog biscuits, but Kimmel assured them that they are not. The celebrity chef first tried the Tagalongs (this author’s favorite), which he seemed OK with. When it came to the Samoa, Ramsay asked if they are always this small. “That’s a bit weird,” he said.

Since Thin Mints should be beloved by all, Ramsay should have liked it… right? Uh… no.

Hell’s Kitchen airs on Wednesdays on Fox at 9 p.m.