Aaron Rodgers is a Super Bowl winning quarterback and a pretty smart guy. But even he thinks he saw a UFO and has a really detailed story about his sighting.

In a recent interview for Nerdist’s You Made It Weird podcast, the Green Bay Packers quarterback said that he saw an unidentified flying object in 2005 when he was visiting New Jersey with his University of California, Berkeley teammate Steve Levy. Rodgers said that the object was large and Levy and his brother also saw it.

“It was a large orange, left-to-right-moving object,” Rodgers explained, notes the Milwaukee Record. “Because of the overcast nature of the night and the snow, you couldn’t make out—it was kind of behind the clouds we were seeing, but it was definitively large, moving from left to right.”

After Levy, Levy’s brother and Rodgers saw the object fly by, the friends had to ask each other, “‘What in the f**k was that?'” Rodgers said.

Rodgers won Super Bowl XLV and won Super Bowl MVP. Last season, he lead the Packers back to the playoffs, with 31 touchdown passes and 3,821 passing yards. Perhaps he can use the UFO story as an idea for his next State Farm commercial.