Jimmy Fallon, Jake Gyllenhaal spit food at each other because… why not?

Jake Gyllenhaal usually stars in some very serious movies, so when he’s on the talk show circuit, he tries to let loose. While on The Tonight Show starring Jimmy Fallon on March 21, he did just that.

Gyllenhaal, who will next be seen in Demolition, starred in a sketch called Point Pleasant Police Department in which he and Fallon were partners. The two can’t stop saying words with “p”s while they eat, so they keep spitting food at each other.

For more food-spitting action, here’s Fallon and Jon Hamm spitting food at each other in Palisades Park Pet Patrol.

Going even further back, here’s Fallon and Alec Baldwin getting their faces messy in another episode of Point Pleasant Police Department.