We’re seeing double as the Olsen twins have finally appeared in a social media selfie together for the first time.

The Mary-Kate and Ashley Instagram selfie was posted by the beauty brand Sephora on April 13 with the caption “First public selfie ever #SephoraTakeover.”

In the photo, the former Full House stars each wore matching black shades and had their hair down; making it hard for us to tell them apart.

After teasing everyone with their first selfie, the twins posted a shot of two glasses with wine along with the caption “First and last day as official Instagrammers #cheers #MyNirvana.”

We’re sad to see them go but now the Internet will always have one selfie of them together.