While Jeremy and Mindy were out at dinner, after getting kicked out of Hamilton, a mystery person pays for their dinner. Who is it other than Casey! Casey is back!! Talk about blast from the past. Mindy decides to give Casey another try.
Over dinner, Casey admits that Mindy was Casey’s one that got away. But wait, Casey doesn’t actually want to date Mindy, even though they had a super romantic dinner. After their broken engagement, Casey’s friends advised him to never date Mindy again.
However, Mindy is determined. She creates a five-step plan to win Casey’s friends’ approval, so she can date him. She manages to win everyone over except for Marcus.
Mindy totally gets turned off from Casey when she takes his shirt off and sees the ridiculous tattoos that he got since they broke up. She really doesn’t want to date Casey anymore, and is contemplating breaking up with him. Ironically, Marcus changes his mind towards Mindy once he sees how stupid happy Casey has been because of Mindy.
Jodi is dating Ashley, the woman who is saving herself for marriage. Turns out Ashley has an anonymous blog that goes into great detail about her love life with Colonel Suspenders (Jodi). Tamra and Morgan actively follow Ashley’s blog. Apparently, Ashley thinks that Jodi dresses too old fashioned. Tamra quickly fixes this by spilling coffee on Jodi’s outfit, and takes him shopping to fix the problem. Ashley updated her blog, praising Jodi’s new wardrobe. However, she feels that Jodi has a crush on someone at his work. Tamra instantly comes to the conclusion that it’s her (even though even one else knows its Mindy).
Ashley encourages Jodi to tell Mindy about his feelings. Mindy confides in Jodi that she actually has a thing for Marcus.