Back at camp, everyone comments on the votes. Andrea instantly talks strategy and is nervous about Reynold. Cochran tells Andrea that the remaining Fans are too strong and wants to curb their comfort by any means necessary. Next morning Cochran reads tree mail. After hearing that an immunity challenge is fast approaching, Erik wants to vote of Reynold.
At the immunity challenge, the players must balance on a triangular platform with their bare feet planted on very thin planks. In different intervals the survivors must move up the platform. The last player standing wins immunity and reward in the form of information in the game.
Throughout the game Jeff tempts the players. The first temptation is donuts and ice cold milk. Eddie and Erik both jump off. The remaining players clap as the pair enjoys their donuts. Shortly after, the players move up the platform.
The next item Jeff tempts the players with is three hotdogs and soda. Cochran immediately jumps off and no one claps for him. When asked, Cochran admits he wasn’t going to last much longer and says as long as one of the core alliance members win everything will go according to plan.
Time elapses and the remaining players move to the top of the pyramid. Once at the top several players struggle to hold on. Reynold has a nice save, Dawn shakes and recovers and Sherri starts trembling but holds on.
A few minutes later Dawn and Sherri fall off leaving Reynold, Brenda and Andrea to battle it out. The wind gust comes, knocking Reynold to the side but he recovers. Brenda shakes but recover as well. Reynold has an incredible recovery but falls shortly after. Jeff notes that the key to winning immunity is focus.
Brenda and Andrea are left to battle it out. The fallen survivors try to persuade them to strike up a deal but neither one budges. Three hours pass by. Brenda suggests to Jeff that they up the ante in game by adding another level. Jeff asks what they want and Brenda says they must lift up their left foot and keep it up for the remainder of the game. Jeff counts them off but Brenda ultimately falls. Andrea wins immunity.
Back at camp, the tribe congratulates Andrea on her win. Reynold tells the audience that it’s time for the tribe to make a huge power move and blindside someone. Sadly he realizes he’s not the conductor of the tribe and his fate rests in their hands.
Andrea begrudgingly shares the clue with Brenda. When they realize it’s the clue to the hidden immunity idol the two go back to camp, share the news with their alliance and then they all go to look for the idol together. Erik surprisingly finds it buried next to a tree but hands it over to Andrea. Cochran notes that it was a bad move.
Andrea tells the alliance that it’s time for a blindside and mentions Brenda’s name as the first to go. Cochran realizes that Andrea is thinking about an end game not just a now game which worries him. He also starts to realize she is a huge threat. After talking to Cochran, Andrea talks to Dawn about a potential blindside and tells her that Brenda needs to go.
At tribal council, when asked, Eddie says he knew he couldn’t last long on the pyramid so he jumped to eat. Jeff notes that the former Stealth R Us alliance claimed to be tight but asks why they lasted so long in the challenge and didn’t just cut a deal. Reynold says he noticed the same thing and thinks that there may be a crack he can wiggle his way into. The alliance starts to question each other. Each member agrees that the paranoia kicks in because they know that they themselves aren’t trustworthy.
The Survivors go and vote. Jeff tallies the votes and then reads them. Erik gets one vote, Sherri gets one vote, Reynold gets four votes and Eddie gets two votes. Reynold is voted out and is the fourth member of the jury.
After tribal council, the alliance is happy that Reynold is gone. Andrea tells the audience that next move to make is a blindside before the alliance member sees it coming and it happens to them. Andrea talks to Cochran and talks about either Brenda or Dawn going first. Cochran doesn’t believe a blindside is good move at this point in the game.
Brenda and Dawn talk strategy with Cochran and say Eddie should be the next to go. Cochran immediately tells them that Andrea threw their name out as the first to go. Angry that Andrea would sell them out that quick, the pair hatch a plot to vote her out if she doesn’t win the next immunity.
At the second immunity challenge, the players must push a buoy through a series of obstacles to obtain a key attached to a post. Once the players obtain the key they must use it to unlock puzzle pieces. The first to complete their ladder puzzle, climb up to the top, and raise their flag will win immunity.
Once the challenge begins, Erik and Brenda are off to a fast start. Erik is first, followed by Dawn, Cochran, and Andrea. All players begin to untie their knots except Sherri who catches up shortly after. Everyone begins to work on their ladder puzzle. In the beginning Andrea and Brenda are neck and neck. Andrea starts to fall behind and Erik passes her as well as Brenda. Erik flies through the challenge and wins immunity.
Before tribal council, Andrea pitches Brenda’s name yet again to Cochran and Dawn. Andrea talks about how bad she feels about blindsiding an alliance member considering that’s the way she went out the last time. Andrea says she not going to play the idol unless she feels paranoid and admits that she is confident she won’t be going home.
Andrea tells Eddie that Brenda is the one going home. She tells Cochran that she can see Eddie going to the finals. Cochran starts to believe that Andrea wants to take Eddie to the finals and that upsets him. Cochran tells Sherri and Erik that they need to vote off Andrea. Erik says he will vote with whoever will advance him the farthest in the game.
At tribal council, Eddie mentions a blindside. Brenda says that lying is going to start to happen at this stage of the game. Cochran says that he’s made promises that he doesn’t plan to keep just like others have. Andrea says she’s nervous and admits that she has an idol. She also says if her paranoia is high enough she will play it. The Survivors go and vote. The votes are read. Brenda has two votes, Eddie has two votes and Andrea has four votes. Andrea is voted out. She screams and tells the tribe that was really good move. Another powerhouse player is sent packing.
The game JUST got seriously real! Wonder what’s going to happen next?
Watch Survivor: Caramoan on Wednesdays at 8 p.m. on CBS